China Expat




Classless Society

I see the same cleaning lady every morning. She’s the size of an Oompa-Loompa, with one of those Southern Chinese faces fine-featured enough to stick in dough and make doll cookies with. Now, Da Shan has no need to get his golden pompadour ruffled over me, but I think I’ve cultivated my “Zao shang hao,” to an authentic timber. So why did it take me eight Mandarin good mornings until she stopped pretending she hadn’t heard me and replied?

 

It wasn’t shyness. I’ve seen her banter with the security guards and other members of her mop brigade, and she’s as feisty as an Ewok chieftain. And, though unschooled, she’s not afraid of foreigners. “Waiguoren ting you yisi,” [Foreigners are very interesting] she told me, after I had battered down the walls of reserve. Walls, ironically enough, mortared by class division.

 

It’s a painful conclusion to make, comrades, since so many died for a land established in the name of the peasant. But the eyes don’t lie. You know what I’m talking about. That magic micro-second of eye contact, too fast to bluff. Like when that erstwhile lovely you’re surreptitiously checking out from your cab unexpectedly looks in your direction, and you realize she was meant for profile shots. She sees and understands your dismay and embarrassment, as you do hers.

 

In those micro-moments with the cleaning lady, I saw confusion and suspicion, suspicion that maybe I was making fun of her. She figured the only reasons a foreigner would have to acknowledge her would be dishonorable.

And that’s a very common perspective amongst the Lilies of China. But that doesn’t explain the confusion I saw. The eyes of all those 1.9 meter, 50 kilogram self-anointed super models stick-figuring around the city hold no confusion during the micro-second. Their eyes usually say, “Oh god, the price of supreme beauty, to be subjected to the depraved leers of these foreign color wolves.”(I couldn’t be projecting here, could I?)

 

Anyway, I don’t see the confusion in the eyes of the praying mantis girls, but I saw it in hers. Because in Beijing, people of one class do not talk to so much as at people of a lower class. And class here is determined by your projected, not actual, net worth. Oh yeah, and your education; I’ll say that for Beijing’s class system. And lacking either, one is deemed unworthy of the niceties that make for human dignity - a tip of the hat, a civil tone.

 

Don’t believe me? How many times have you been the guest of honor at a nice Chinese dinner? Why do your hosts insist you try the dishes first, and keep the cross-cultural clichés flying? “Ha, ha, do you like Chinese food? Do you like NBA?” Of course, it’s gracious, but only a function of the instant status you command as a foreigner. Witness the Jekyll-Hyde transformation in your smiling host when the humble waitress needs a dressing down:

“Ha ha. You can say xie xie. Your Chinese is so good – Eh! Fuwu yuaRR! Ni ganshenmedeBLAHRAHRGAHR!! TIAN-AH!!"

 

To be sure, class-prejudice is a universal plague. As a teenager, I spent a summer sweating over a wood grill in the back of a fish n’ chips shack at the end of a pier at a yacht club. The yacht club teens would saunter in and sneer at me and the kitchen crew, and we’d drop their lobster rolls on the floor and fart on their fries. Mine is not a special story – it permeates the fabric of social interaction.

 

I guess what I have to accept is that back in the U.S.A. we have this cherished fiction of equality we must cling to, publicly at least. Because if even Maury Rosenberg, or whoever runs Paramount Studios, were to unload on the wait-staff at Morton's like petty tyrants do here in the Jing, well…. Well for starters, he’d be the one to lose face, not the kitchen cipher. Furthermore, he’d stand a distinct chance of getting a Mexican knuckle-sandwich for lunch, and another one on the house.

 

But the Chinese rank and file are a passive bunch. The fact that their “betters” are better off only from welching on the better promise of a better world for the rank and file, they seem to bear philosophically. I’m the one with the problem, biting my fist because the messenger boy stands cringing in the doorway until he is bid to enter, because the ayi has to mind and feed the baby at the restaurant, but may not partake of the viands. Someone call me when the real revolution starts.

 

Share This Post with




Comments

"But the Chinese rank and

"But the Chinese rank and file are a passive bunch."

Isn't that the key to a harmonious society ?



Knock knock

Anyone home ?



Every single Chinese person

Every single Chinese person either Professor of Long March Studies at RenDa, or DVD vendor at YaShow realizes that the Middle Kingdom, Republic of China, or Peoples Republic of China has never ever been a classless society. Despite what lip-service the party continues to broadcast on the CCTV1 News at 7 each night, locals just aren't listening; they are much too busy watching Supergirl or Downloaded Prison Break. In fact the only people I have encountered who ever seem to bring up the PRC's socialist origins are english teachers who watch CCTV9 because they simply can't afford to live in a nice gaff that might provide foreign broadcasted satellite TV.
This will never be a classless societey, and as white/black/latino/ or other asian you are always going to simply be part of the foreign class. Let's celebrate it, where else in the world can you commit a minor felony, and walk away after the police arrive simply by pleading ignorance of local law. I would prefer to stay part of the discriminated foreign class, then part of the horde that the people's govt would much rather identify by serial number than family name. But, be my guest and keep fighting for equality.
My 2 cents.



Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

Beijing Olympics Guide


There is a lot of information on this site. Just type in your keyword and go!


China Expat City Guide

Select City


Dezan Shira & Associates
China Expat is brought to you by Dezan Shira & Associates, China’s largest independent legal and tax consultancy, specializing in foreign direct investment into China. We are the only such firm with a specific national Chinese culture research team. To learn more about the services we offer to foreign investors, please visit our website here with full details of all office contacts.

Dezan Shira & Associates
Click here to access our award winning China Briefing Daily News site with all the latest on topics affecting international business in China